The US M1910 Canteen with Cup: A Reenactor's Field Notes
The M1910 canteen is one of those bits of kit you stop noticing after the first hour. It sits on your hip, it sloshes a little when you walk, and then around two in the afternoon on a hot field it turns into the single most important thing you're carrying. This post is about our US M1910 Canteen with Cup, a new reproduction of the one quart aluminum canteen and nesting cup, and about the original it copies.
I portray a doughboy for most of the season and a 1944 GI at a couple of summer events, so I've filled, dropped, scrubbed and boiled coffee in a fair few of these. I've got opinions. Some of them might even be right.
Where the M1910 Canteen Came From
The story starts in 1909, when the Army's Equipment Board decided to get rid of the old hemispherical canteen and replace it with a new one quart canteen in aluminum. The first M1910 canteens were made in 1910 by the Aluminum Goods Manufacturing Company, which marked its work AGM Co. In 1918 the Quartermaster Corps contracted five domestic firms to turn out canteens for the troops going to Europe.
The shape is the clever bit. Seen from above the body is a curved kidney, so it hugs the hip instead of sticking out like a bottle, and the cup slides over the bottom half and nests with it. That cup, with its folding handle, did a lot more than hold water. Coffee, soup, whatever you could heat up.
And those WWI contract canteens didn't get thrown away when the Armistice came. They stayed in use into the 1940s and the early days of the Second World War. So a 1918 dated canteen on an early war impression isn't wrong at all (people argue about this at the mess tent, and it's a strange hill to choose).
1942 and the Aluminum Problem
This is where most of the variants come from. Once the US was in the war, aluminum was wanted for aircraft and there wasn't enough to go round. Beginning in 1942, canteens were made from substitute materials. The main one was corrosion resistant steel, which collectors call CRS or just stainless, built to the same M1910 design with a different material and a different method of manufacture. The solder on those contained lead, and there were concerns about contamination, especially if you put anything acidic in it. There was also a trial of porcelain enamel M1942 canteens, which didn't work out.
But the aluminum shortage for canteens didn't last long. In late 1942 the War Production Board released aluminum for canteen manufacture again. The first aluminum canteens after the ban came from firms that had been making the CRS type, so they carry a horizontal seam. The more traditional welded aluminum canteen with the side seam went back into production from 1943. Wartime examples have a dull finish and are marked with US, the maker's initials and the year, handy when you're squinting at a dealer's table.
The cap change
The cap is the detail that gives an impression away fastest. From 1942 the metal cap was replaced with a black resin plastic (Bakelite) cap with a cork disc seal. The first version was 3/4 inch high and flat on top. In 1943 it was redesigned to one inch high, a touch smaller in diameter, with a recessed top that protected the chain rivet.
So the rule of thumb for living history is simple enough. A WWI or interwar impression wants the aluminum cap. A 1942 or later impression can take the black plastic one. What bugs me is seeing a plastic cap on a 1917 impression, because it's the one thing on the belt anyone can spot from twenty feet.
What You Get With This US M1910 Canteen with Cup
The US M1910 Canteen with Cup has a cast aluminum body. It comes fitted with the early style aluminum cap, and the later black plastic cap is included too, so one canteen covers both wars if you're happy to swap caps between events. The set also includes an aluminum M1910 canteen cup with a folding handle.
A few honest notes from the customer reviews, since I'd rather you heard them here than found out at an event:
- One buyer found it a very tight fit in a WWI cover bought at the same time. Soaking the cover in water and letting it dry helped a bit.
- A couple of buyers found swapping to the plastic cap fiddly, and one couldn't make the switch on one of two canteens.
- A couple of collectors felt the cup's kidney shape or height differs slightly from their originals.
None of that would put me off.
Carrying It in the Field
A full quart on the hip is heavier than you remember, and you feel it by the end of a long tactical. In a cover hooked to the eyelets of a cartridge belt it settles in fine, though (one reviewer bought theirs to go with an original 1903 cartridge belt, which is about as right as it gets for the early period).
On a cold morning the cup is the thing I reach for first. Fill it, set it at the edge of the fire, and wait. The folding handle gets hot, so use a glove or a bit of rag unless you like burnt fingers. Ask me how I know.
Care is dull but it matters. Empty it after an event, rinse it out, and let it dry with the cap off. Anyway, a reproduction you can actually drink from also means your originals can stay in the cabinet where they belong.
Plastic canteens eventually took over from the metal M1910 in US service, but for anything from the Punitive Expedition era through the Second World War, this is the shape that belongs on the belt. Go straight to the US M1910 Canteen with Cup listing if you want one on yours.
What Our Customers Say About It
One collector who compared it with the real thing wrote that the canteen is "by far the most accurate, with only very minor difference from the original wartime canteen comparing them side by side." Another, who'd swapped in their own chain and cork gasket, said "Nailed the canteen perfectly. Cup is a hair short, but still a superb reproduction, with a nice sturdy handle. No 70+ year old gunk to worry about either."
A reenactor covering the early years put it simply: "Just the thing I need to portray a U.S. Soldier of the era from the Mexican Punitive Expedition under Gen. J.J. Pershing thru the great war." One buyer also noted it "fits cover good". More on the customer reviews page.
Disclaimer: Historical information provided for educational purposes only. For accurate product specifications and details, please check our product pages, reviews, or contact customer service.
Experience a piece of history for yourself! Check out our authentic reproduction of US M1910 Canteen with Cup (Reproduction) here: Get Your US M1910 Canteen with Cup (Reproduction)












